Norwegian Institute for Air Research
Netherlands Institute for Ecology
Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research
Institute for Environmental Studies, Free University Amsterdam
University of Plymouth
Centre for Social and Economic Research on the Global Environment
Land-Ocean Interactions in the Coastal Zone
 


Contaminants: Budgets and Behaviours
Synthesis Results

3. Fluvial supply to the coast (1 of 2)

 
The focus of projects has been upon potential anthropogenic impacts, and upon the associated processes and circumstances. In general, focus was not primarily upon overall budgeting of the European coastal seas. With general riverine flux data widely collated by state agencies, and although somewhat dispersed and variable, data has always thus existed from which basic estimates of fluvial contaminants to the coastal zone could be made.

The ELOISE projects evaluating specifically riverine contaminant supplies are BIOGEST (estuarine biogas, northern Europe – commented in section 5. Atmospheric pathways: from sea to land), EROS-21 (Black Sea), EUROCAT (various), and TOROS (metal contamination, S.Spain). In addition, of partial relevance are the fluvial projects dealing with nutrients DANUBS (Black Sea), INCA (various), MANTRA-EAST (north-east) and STREAMES ( Mediterranean).

Metal mining at present and as a legacy has provided one theme of research into riverine transport of metal contaminants to the coast. The TOROS project focuses on fluvial transport from the long term mining regions around Rio Tinto and Rio Odiel to the coast of southern Spain. Chronic release (2500 years), mine drainage, phosphogypsum waste runoff and acute discharge (collapse of Los Frailes tailings dam, Aznalcollar) are features of this case study. Comparison of the total transport of some metals drawn with other European river systems is a measure of the severe situation. Contaminant flows to Western Mediterranean were also investigated by TOROS (Table 2). For example, mercury concentrations flowing into the Bay of Cadiz are put at ten times greater than those transported by the Seine to the Normandy coast, generally held to be a relatively contaminated river. Comparisons with mine impacted rivers in the UK also shows the Rio Tinto to be a much more heavily metal laden river (Braungardt et al., 2003). Acidic and metal rich waters exist down as far as salinities of 30 o/ oo in the estuary.

Physical characteristics of transport are explored to examine the sink mechanisms operating. Removal of mercury (Hg), aresenic (As), and uranium (U) by sediment and also seasonally by algae fixation (Elbaz-Poulichetet al., 2000) during transport to the coast is contrasted with limited removal of other metals in the coarse of downstream transport. Precipitation of dissolved components and co-precipitation with iron is also observed, and the factors dictating suspended particulate-dissolved metal relationships explored (Achterberg et al., 2003).

The project also attempts to budget the estimates of metal inputs into the western Mediterranean Sea, by rivers, modelling dispersion along the coast, and through the Straits of Gibraltar (Elbaz-Poulichetet al., 2001a & Elbaz-Poulichetet al., 2001b). These figures indicate that for components other than arsenic the Rio Tinto is far from an inconsiderable source of total inputs. That this Mediterranean river system is so much more heavily metal laden than other local rivers, indicates the long term legacy which can result from mining in Europe. Simultaneoulsy, evaluation of the effects of acute release with the Los Frailes tailings dam collapse indicated no impact on coastal chemistry after six months (Elbaz-Poulichet et al., 1961-1973). Of course, the high existing baseline should be recognised when interpreting such an assessment.

    Cu Zn Cd As
Direct input Rivers 230 130 3 200
Atmosphere 600-1200 3200-5100 35-60  
ViaStraits of Gibraltar Atlantic waters 1140 1010 45 24000
Rio Tinto etc./ Gulf of Cadiz 2000 6300 100 6300
Ouflow to Atlantic -1300 -6900 - -33000
Table 2. Contaminant flows to Western Mediterranean, tonnes per year (from TOROS). Negative numbers indicate flow out of the Mediterranean
 

Another case with restricted long term consequences of elevated contaminant discharge is the Danube . The EROS-21 project demonstrated that despite high discharges in the past before recent economic changes, at present the fluvial flows of contaminants into the Black Sea from the Danube are not generally high (Guieu & Martin, 2002). Only copper and lead show elevated inputs of metals in particulate form, with copper alone being elevated in dissolved form. The source of this is believed to be upstream mining. Release from surface runoff or contaminated sediments does not seem to be a particular issue. The Danube system, notable as a transnational river open to variable control strategies, does not appear to act as a conduit for elevated metal input to the Black Sea. Indeed, it appears able to ameliorate both any release of metals to the river system further upstream, and release from sediment. Amongst organic contaminants, organochlorine levels were found to be ‘average’ for European rivers. HCH registers higher, this being evidence of continued lindane use within the catchment (Maldonado & Bayona, 2002).

A further evaluation undertaken within the EROS-21 project was to review the rate of transmission of radioactive material along the river courses (Gulin et al., 2002), as a result of radioactivity arising from the Chernobyl accident. A five-ten year delay was observed before the peak inflow of radioactivity occurred in the Danube and Dnieper.


<< Contaminants Contents - back-to-top - next page 2 of 2 >>